Chapter 2 - THE WOMAN WITH SARAH'S NAME
By morning, the photograph of a stranger using Sarah Moretti’s name had become the most frightening thing in my hospital room.
Luca sent it through a secure message after the police gave permission for me to see it. The woman was in her forties, perhaps older, with dark hair pulled back from a pale face. She stood beside a gray house with narrow windows and winter-bare trees. She was not Sarah. Even in photographs, I could tell. Sarah had been laughing in almost every picture Sophie kept. This woman looked as though she had forgotten what laughter sounded like.
But beneath the photograph was an intake form bearing the name SARAH MORETTI, LEGAL GUARDIAN.
I kept staring at those words.
My own mother, Evelyn Dawson, arrived just after dawn, wrapped in a worn brown coat. She leaned over the bed, kissed my forehead, and then looked at the splint around my leg.
“Oh, my girl.”
“I’m okay, Mom.”
She raised an eyebrow. “We both know you aren’t.”
She had a careful way of speaking when she was frightened. It came from years of managing the world with a chronic illness and an income that never quite covered everything. I had taken the Moretti job because the pay was steady, and because the pension she received after working thirty-two years as a public school secretary did not stretch to her medications and rent.
“I shouldn’t have stayed there,” she said quietly.
“You didn’t know.”
“I knew you were tired. Every phone call sounded like you were apologizing for existing.”
That hurt because it was true.
Mrs. Alvarez arrived with coffee for both of us and an update from the house. Vanessa had left the mansion late at night, accompanied by her father. Luca had called an attorney, dismissed the catering staff, and canceled all wedding arrangements. Sophie was sleeping in his room, apparently unwilling to let him out of her sight.
“And how is he?” my mother asked.
Mrs. Alvarez hesitated. “Like a father who just learned someone tried to take his child.”
At nine, a detective named Rebecca Morales came to take my statement. She wore a dark coat over a navy suit and carried a small notebook, though she also set a recorder on the bedside table after asking my permission.
“Start with the braid,” she said.
I told her about Vanessa’s order to cut Sophie’s hair. I told her how Sarah had left the ribbon, how Luca tied it on important days, and how I refused to remove it. I described the punch, the drawer, the staircase, and the long minutes I spent trying to stand. When I reached the moment Sophie found me, my throat closed.
Detective Morales waited.
“She said, ‘We have to go to Daddy,’” I whispered. “She helped me down the hall. She’s eleven. She shouldn’t have had to do that.”
“Was anyone else present when Vanessa assaulted you?”
“No.”
“Did you see what she used to strike your face?”
“Her hand. She had a large ring on.”
“And the fall?”
“She pushed me.”
Morales made notes, then looked up. “You don’t need to make your story stronger for me, Claire. The details you remember are enough. If you’re unsure about anything, say so.”
That simple permission almost made me cry again. At the mansion, certainty had belonged to people with money. Everyone else was supposed to agree.
“Did you know Vanessa had prepared documents about Sophie?” the detective asked.
“I knew she disliked the blue ribbon. I knew she talked about boarding school. I didn’t know about the transport.”
“What about Sarah Moretti’s estate?”
I thought of the locked sewing cabinet. “I knew she left Sophie a few sentimental things. I never saw legal papers.”
Morales nodded. “We’re obtaining records now. Please avoid discussing the case publicly or trying to investigate on your own.”
Before she left, she handed me contact information for a victim advocate. She explained how medical records, photographs, and pay statements could help document my losses and support any protective measures I needed. Her manner was calm enough that I started to believe I could be more than the wounded girl on the ballroom floor.
At the mansion that same morning, Sophie refused breakfast until her father promised they would eat together. I learned this because Luca called while my mother was helping me adjust my pillows.
“Would you speak to her?” he asked. “She keeps asking whether you’re coming back.”
I hesitated. “Does she know I’m in the hospital?”
“She knows you’re being treated. I didn’t hide it.”
Sophie’s voice burst through the phone. “Miss Claire? Does your leg have a robot on it?”
I laughed despite the pain. “It has a splint, not a robot.”
“That sounds disappointing.”
“Very.”
A pause followed. “Did they get mad at you for making trouble?”
“No, sweetheart. The doctors are helping me.”
“Vanessa said doctors only like people with good insurance.”
I closed my eyes. “She was wrong about a lot of things.”
Luca cleared his throat. “Sophie, there’s something I need to ask Claire.”
She protested, then eventually handed him the phone. He sounded different from the man I knew. Less commanding. More careful.
“Claire, did Sarah ever mention a woman named Helen Voss?”
“No. Who is she?”
“The woman who used Sarah’s name on the transport paperwork. Her real name appears to be Helen Voss.”
“What does she do?”
“That’s the question. The property belongs to a company called Bellini Family Services.”
My stomach tightened. “Vanessa’s family?”
“It’s registered through two other corporations, but my attorney believes it leads back to Carlo.”
I could hear Daniel speaking in the background, and then a chair moving across the floor.
“Luca,” I asked, “why use Sarah’s name?”
He took a breath. “There’s a clause in Sarah’s estate plan. If I die or become legally incapable of acting as guardian, Sophie’s education and living expenses are overseen by a trustee Sarah chose. That trustee has significant authority, though not the right to abduct her. Someone may be trying to create paperwork that appears to activate the clause.”
“But you’re alive, and you’re capable.”
“Yes.” His voice turned hard. “I am.”
He paused. “Sarah had disagreements with my family before she died. She insisted on an independent trustee to keep Sophie’s inheritance separate from the business. I thought she was being overly cautious.”
“Who is the trustee?”
“An attorney named Miriam Park. I’m meeting her this afternoon.”
After the call, my mother squeezed my hand. “You have to let them handle this.”
“I know.”
“You’ve already done more than anyone should ask of you.”
I nodded. But I could still see Sophie standing beside me on the dining room floor, clutching that awful piece of paper. The thought of anyone putting her in a car she didn’t want to enter made my chest feel tight.
At noon, Mrs. Alvarez returned and placed a small cardboard box on my bedside table. It contained my sweater, my worn purse, and a pair of flats. Daniel had asked one of the housekeepers to bring them from my room. Everything smelled faintly of laundry soap and the lavender sachets Mrs. Alvarez tucked into drawers.
There was also a folded note from Sophie, written in purple marker.
PLEASE COME BACK WHEN YOUR LEG IS BETTER. DADDY SAYS YOU CAN PICK THE MOVIE. NO SCARY ONES. LOVE, SOPHIE.
I held it against my chest.
Then something slipped from beneath the sweater. It was a photograph I did not recognize: Sarah standing in a garden, cradling a toddler Sophie. Beside her stood a younger woman whose face was partly hidden by a sunhat.
I turned it over. A message had been written in neat black ink.
To Miriam. If anything happens, remember the ribbon. Sarah.
My heart began to race. The photograph had not been in my purse when Vanessa attacked me. Someone had placed it there afterward.
I called Mrs. Alvarez back into the room. She looked at the picture and went still.
“That’s Mrs. Moretti,” she said.
“I know. Who is the other woman?”
“Miriam Park. Sarah’s college roommate, I think. She came to the house a few times before the funeral.”
“Why would Sarah tell her to remember the ribbon?”
Mrs. Alvarez frowned. “I don’t know. But Sarah used to sew. She embroidered little labels inside Sophie’s dresses so they wouldn’t get mixed up at preschool.”
I looked at the photograph again. Sarah’s smile was bright, but her fingers were closed firmly around the little blue ribbon tied to Sophie’s braid. Had she been protecting a memory? A document? Or simply a child who would one day need to know she had been loved?
The answer came sooner than I expected.
At two forty-seven, Miriam Park called my hospital room. Her voice was low and precise.
“Miss Dawson, Luca showed me the photograph. I need you to tell me exactly where you found it.”
I explained. She listened without interrupting.
“Sarah sent me a copy of that photograph four years ago,” Miriam said. “It was taken the week before she died.”
“Why?”
“Because she believed someone was moving money out of Sophie’s trust. She wanted a record of what she had entrusted to me.”
I looked at the photograph and felt the room grow smaller.
“What does the ribbon mean?”
There was a long pause.
“It means Sarah knew someone close to Luca would try to replace her instructions with false ones.”
May you like
Then Miriam said the words that made my heart drop.
“Claire, I was supposed to meet Sarah the morning she died. She never arrived. And her car accident was never properly explained to me.”
