Chapter 3 - A DEATH CERTIFICATE WITHOUT A BODY
Three days after Lily's interrupted birthday party, the police informed Luca that Noah's identity had been confirmed by a laboratory comparison with retained family reference samples.
He called me after receiving the news, and for nearly a minute he said nothing.
“Hannah?” he finally whispered.
“I'm here.”
“He's my boy.”
I pressed my free hand over my mouth. I had never doubted what I saw when Noah opened the music box. Still, certainty on paper mattered when powerful people were prepared to dispute everything else.
“How is he?”
“He asked whether he has to change his name immediately. I told him he doesn't have to decide today.” Luca gave a small, broken laugh. “He said Eli is the name Grace uses when she's proud of him, and Noah is the name he hears in his dreams. What was I supposed to say?”
“You said the right thing.”
“I said he could use both until he wanted something different.”
“Then you did.”
Luca went quiet. “There was another call this morning. The county's missing-person unit has reopened the death determination. My lawyers can't find a valid basis for the document Michael showed me three years ago.”
The paper Luca meant was one I'd heard about during my first month at the mansion. A small boy had vanished six years earlier. Three years into the search, an identification report from another state had suggested he was among the victims of a building fire. Luca had gone to the memorial service alone. A month later he stopped setting a place for Noah at the breakfast table, though the tiny blue bowl remained in the back of the cupboard.
“What does that mean?” I asked.
“That I buried a name, not a child.”
I didn't know how to answer that. There was grief in his voice, and something sharper than grief: the knowledge that someone had used his love to injure him.
The next afternoon, Detective Vega visited my mother's apartment with an investigator from the state attorney's office. They were following a financial trail linking the placement agency to an entity called Bellini Family Services. I wasn't being asked to identify financial crimes. They wanted to establish what Vanessa had said about Lily in the weeks before the party and whether I had noticed unfamiliar children at the estate.
I remembered one afternoon when Vanessa had ordered me to prepare two sets of children's clothes, one for a six-year-old girl and another for a boy roughly Lily's size. She called them donations to a charity drive. When I'd asked where the bags should go, she'd told me to place them near a sealed staff entrance rather than the donation van.
“I wrote it in the household log,” I told Vega. “Mrs. Carter has the logbook.”
“Do you know the date?”
“Last Tuesday. I was scheduled to work the evening shift because Lily wanted help decorating cupcakes.”
Vega thanked me and asked whether I had noticed a particular man at the house: Julian Pike, who had worked for a private records firm. I recognized the name from a package addressed to Michael several months earlier, but I had never met him. She wrote it down without suggesting what it proved.
After the investigators left, my mother looked at the little pile of bills we'd arranged on her coffee table.
“Are you going back to work there?” she asked.
“I don't think I can.”
“Good.”
I laughed despite myself. “That sounded surprisingly quick.”
“I've been practicing my answer since the day you came home with a bruise and told me you'd bumped into a door.”
My smile disappeared. I remembered that bruise, and the way I'd pretended not to see her worry. I had kept the job because it paid more than anything else I could find. But I had also become so accustomed to threats that I could no longer tell the difference between a difficult employer and a dangerous one.
“I need time to heal,” I said.
“You need more than that.” My mother touched my hand. “You need to know your life is yours.”
That night, while she slept, I looked through the photographs stored on my phone. There were pictures of birthday decorations, grocery lists, Lily's drawings, Teresa Moretti's Christmas cookies. On a rainy afternoon eight months earlier, I'd photographed a shelf in Luca's study so I could put everything back in the same order after dusting. Behind a brass clock sat a small framed picture of a woman with dark hair and a boy in blue overalls.
Sofia Moretti.
Luca's late wife.
She had died four years earlier after a long illness, two years after Noah vanished. I had never known her, but Mrs. Carter said Sofia used to sing as she moved through the house. When Noah disappeared, she searched for him even as her health worsened. Luca had once told me, in an unguarded moment, that he thought the endless waiting had stolen the last years she should have had.
There had been another photograph on the shelf: Sofia kneeling in a garden, holding three-year-old Noah's hands. In the background, a woman with pale blond hair stood beside the gate. I enlarged the picture on my phone. The woman's face was partly turned away, and there was no way to know who she was. Yet something about the pale hair bothered me.
I sent the photograph to Vega with a note explaining exactly when I'd taken it and that I couldn't identify the woman. She replied that the original image and its provenance would matter more than my impression. I was grateful she didn't pretend a blurred figure had solved anything.
Two days later Luca asked whether he could visit, bringing a small gift from Lily. My mother opened the door and made him wait until I told her I was ready. He entered carrying a paper bag, looking as though he had never quite learned what to do with his expensive coat in a room where everyone hung their own jackets.
“Lily says the picture you cut was the only one where her hair looked perfect,” he said. “She also says it was worth cutting because Noah couldn't breathe in that room.”
My throat tightened.
He handed me a drawing. Lily had drawn a purple cake beneath a bright yellow sun. Underneath she'd written, with a backward R: WE CAN MAKE ANOTHER PICTURE.
I pressed the paper against my chest. “Tell her I love it.”
“She wants to tell you herself when you're well enough. No hurry.” He sat only when my mother offered a chair. “I also wanted to apologize for something specific. You should never have had to risk your life to make me recognize that my children were missing from a birthday party in my own home.”
“You were in another room.”
“I employed the people guarding those doors. That wasn't an accident.”
I studied his face. He looked exhausted, but his attention stayed on the person speaking. It was a difference I could feel.
“What's happening with Noah's placement?” I asked.
“Grace has agreed to a meeting with the child specialist. Noah asked to see her, and they're arranging it. A judge will review the immediate care and custody arrangements while the abduction investigation continues. They haven't promised me a quick answer, and I'm not asking them to.”
“He's nine,” I said. “He's had six years of birthdays and illnesses and school mornings that you weren't allowed to know about.”
“I know.” Luca looked at his hands. “I keep wanting to ask him everything. His favorite food. Who taught him to swim. Whether he remembers Sofia. And every time I start, I see him watching my face to find out which answer will make me happy.”
“Then ask him what he wants you to know.”
Luca nodded slowly. “Grace said he likes trains. He built a whole station from cardboard. I ordered a model train yesterday, and then I cancelled it.”
“Why?”
“Because I thought maybe I should ask before filling his room with things.”
My mother, listening from the kitchen, called out, “That boy already has a life. Learn it before you decorate it.”
Luca looked startled. Then he smiled for the first time. “Yes, ma'am.”
Before he left, he mentioned that the estate's legal team had obtained the original report used to persuade him Noah had died. The document had been emailed to him by Michael's personal assistant. It was not a final forensic identification. It contained a note saying the listed remains were unsuitable for direct DNA comparison and that identity had been inferred from personal effects.
“What personal effects?” I asked.
“A blue knit cap. And a small child's shoe.”
I remembered the music box Noah carried out from behind the wall. The boy had preserved one object that belonged to him. Someone else had apparently supplied two different objects to support a story of his death.
“Did they know whose they were?”
“They never established it. A prosecutor will have to determine who altered or concealed the report. But Michael was the person who told us the inquiry was finished.”
Luca stood at the door, his face gray with fatigue.
“I made Sofia sit through meeting after meeting where investigators said the leads were gone,” he said quietly. “She told me something felt wrong. I thought she couldn't accept the uncertainty. I asked her to stop searching because I couldn't bear to watch her hurt herself.”
He swallowed. “She died believing I had given up.”
I wished I could make that statement less painful. I couldn't.
“Maybe she died knowing she'd never stopped,” I said. “Those aren't the same thing.”
He looked at me for a long time, then nodded and left.
The following morning, Vega called with an update she was authorized to share. The former clerk from the placement agency had located a duplicate intake ledger. On the date Noah disappeared, a three-year-old boy had been entered under the temporary name Eli Winter. The intake form listed an adult woman who supposedly surrendered custody.
The woman's name was Sofia Moretti.
I gripped the phone. “But Sofia was searching for him that whole time.”
“That's why we're investigating the form,” Vega said. “The signature appears inconsistent with verified specimens. We have no basis to treat it as authentic.”
I looked toward the photograph of Sofia in my phone. A young mother kneeling in a garden. A toddler laughing up at her. A woman at the gate whose face I couldn't see.
May you like
Somewhere, someone had tried to make the world believe Sofia had given her son away.
And somebody had known that a forged mother's signature could be more powerful than a father's desperate search.
