Chapter 2 - TWO BABIES IN THE SAME NIGHT

Claire had spent most of her adult life believing her mother cried only at funerals and old movies. Hearing that frightened sob through the hospital phone was worse than any threat Vanessa had made.
“Mom,” she said, gripping the blanket with her uninjured hand, “what does that mean?”
“Come home,” Margaret Morgan whispered. “Please. Don't talk about this over the phone.”
“I can't. They just stitched my arm, and I have to get my shoulder checked again.”
“Stitched your arm?” Her mother's voice rose. “What happened?”
“I'll explain. But first, did you know Sofia Reyes?”
A long silence followed. In the background Claire could hear the familiar hum of her mother's kitchen refrigerator.
“I knew her sister,” Margaret said at last. “And I knew the night Sofia gave birth. I was there.”
Before Claire could ask another question, the line went dead.
She tried calling back. No answer.
At two in the morning, Luca came to the hospital with Daniel and a woman in a gray wool coat. He didn't enter Claire's room until a nurse asked whether she wanted visitors.
The woman introduced herself as Evelyn Park, an attorney who specialized in medical privacy and elder-care abuse. Her voice was level, her handshake brief, her eyes attentive.
“I'm here because Mr. Moretti wants to arrange a lawful review of the clinic records,” Evelyn explained. “He also asked me to make certain you understand your options regarding the assault.”
Claire stared at Luca. “You came here for legal paperwork?”
“Not just paperwork,” he said. “How are you feeling?”
“Like a picture frame fell on me.”
One corner of his mouth moved, almost a smile. “Fair.”
The humor vanished quickly. His phone lay face-down on the table, and he looked as though he hadn't slept.
Claire held out her own phone. “I got a message. Someone knows my mother.”
She showed him the screen. Luca read it twice.
“Can we keep a copy?” Evelyn asked. “And would you be comfortable giving a statement to the police?”
Claire glanced at the bandage on her arm. “Yes. But I don't want my mother dragged into this without warning.”
“We'll speak to her respectfully,” Evelyn said. “Her consent matters.”
Luca pulled a chair closer, leaving a careful distance between them. “What did she tell you?”
“That there were two babies born that night. She stopped before she could explain.”
Daniel, standing near the door, went rigid.
Claire noticed. “Do you know something?”
Daniel shook his head too quickly.
Luca turned toward him. “Daniel.”
“I heard an old rumor,” the security chief admitted. “Your mother was supposed to have lost a child before you. People said she never recovered from it.”
“I was born in 1991,” Luca said. “There was no child before me.”
“That's what I believed.”
Evelyn folded her hands. “Rumors are not records. Let's find the documents.”
Luca's gaze stayed on Daniel for a second longer. “And let's stop treating family history like forbidden territory.”
During the quiet hours before dawn, Claire thought about the photograph again. She opened it on her phone and studied the child's face. Luca's baby cheeks, a dark curl of hair, the tiny hand clenched against a nurse's collar. It was odd to realize that an image could be ordinary and devastating at once.
Her nurse came in to check the dressing. "Pain level?" she asked.
"About a six. Less if I don't move."
"Then don't test it by moving," the nurse said with a gentle smile. "You've got an injury that needs attention, not a test of character to pass."
Claire laughed weakly. She had spent years treating exhaustion as proof of reliability. She suddenly wondered how many times she'd told herself to keep working because someone richer had decided that her discomfort wasn't important.
The nurse reviewed warning signs, follow-up care, and the need for someone to stay with her after discharge. Claire listened, asked questions, and wrote down the number to call if her wound became hot or swollen. Outside the window an ambulance arrived beneath the emergency entrance. There were other people suffering in the night. Her story was not the only emergency, but it deserved care just as much as theirs.
Morning brought rain that turned the hospital windows into sheets of silver. Claire's scans showed no fracture, but the physician warned her to rest, watch for signs of infection, and return for follow-up. She signed the discharge papers with stiff fingers.
Luca offered a car. Claire accepted only after he agreed that the driver would take her to her mother's modest house in Bridgeport rather than back to the estate.
The house smelled of coffee and peppermint. A faded quilt lay over the sofa, and the small table by the front window held Margaret's pill organizer and a vase of chrysanthemums. These ordinary things steadied Claire more than she expected.
Margaret opened the door, saw the bandage and bruised eye, and embraced her carefully.
“Oh, my girl.”
“I'm okay, Mom.”
“You look like you've had the worst night of your life.”
“It's competing with a few others.”
They sat at the kitchen table. Luca waited on the porch until Claire asked him inside. He entered without the bodyguards who normally moved around him like shadows. In the little kitchen his expensive coat looked out of place.
Margaret studied his face. “You have Elena's eyes.”
Luca swallowed. “You knew my mother?”
“I cleaned for her aunt when I was young. Later, I helped a nurse at a small private home on Archer Avenue. Sofia Reyes was there in the winter of 1991.”
“Why?” Luca asked.
Margaret rubbed her hands. “Because she was terrified. She'd been involved with a man who promised to protect her, then abandoned her when she became pregnant. There were people searching for her, and she didn't trust the hospital.”
“Was that man my father?”
“I don't know,” Margaret said. “I never saw him.”
She stood slowly and retrieved a metal cookie tin from the top of the pantry. Inside were birthday candles, faded Christmas photographs, a hospital bracelet, and an envelope sealed with yellowed tape.
“I was told to hold this until Sofia was safe,” she said. “Then the woman who gave it to me disappeared.”
“Who?” Claire asked.
“Marisol Reyes. Sofia's younger sister.”
She opened the envelope. There were two infant footprints on separate hospital slips, both marked with the same date. One had the name BABY REYES, MALE. The other read BABY REYES, FEMALE.
Claire felt a strange lurch in her stomach.
“Twins?” Luca asked.
Margaret nodded. “A boy and a girl. The boy was taken away that night. I was told he would be safe with Elena and Michael Moretti. The girl stayed with Sofia for three days.”
“What happened to her?”
Margaret pressed her lips together. “Someone came for the baby. A man wearing a hospital coat. Sofia fought him. She fell and struck her head. By the time help arrived, the girl was gone.”
Claire stared at the second footprint. “You never told me.”
“I was twenty-two. I was afraid. Later, when I asked, people told me the little girl had died. I didn't know what to believe.”
Luca rose. He went to the window, one hand braced on its frame. Claire could imagine how it felt to discover the family he'd mourned had hidden not just his birth but the existence of a sister.
“Did Elena know?” he asked without turning.
“She helped arrange the boy's adoption,” Margaret replied. “But I think she was looking for the girl until the day she died.”
Evelyn, who had arrived separately at Claire's request, examined the documents. “These are important leads, but we'll need original records and independent verification. The baby bracelets alone can't establish identity.”
Margaret carefully laid the two footprint slips side by side. Their ink was faded, but the hand-written time stamps were only minutes apart. She pointed to a tiny notation beneath the girl's print.
"See these initials? M.R. Marisol insisted on witnessing both records because somebody had already offered Sofia money to sign papers she didn't understand. I was asked to bring food and blankets, but Marisol made me stay while the nurse copied the slips. She said someday there would be people who denied either child was born."
"Did anyone call the police when the girl disappeared?" Evelyn asked.
"Yes. A patrol officer arrived. Another man in a suit spoke to him in the hall. After that, the officer wrote that the infant had been transferred for treatment. Nobody could tell us to where."
"Do you remember the officer's name?"
Margaret shook her head. "I wrote the badge number once, but we moved three times after your father lost his job, Claire. The notebook may have been thrown away."
Claire took her mother's hand. "You saved enough to bring us here. You were young and they were frightening."
"I wish that were enough to make me feel better," Margaret said. "I used to think about that little girl on her birthdays. I wondered whether somebody was telling her she was loved."
Luca looked at the two slips, not at either woman. "No one even told me I had someone sharing my birthday."
"Elena wanted to," Margaret whispered. "I know she did. But Silvio kept warning her that the girl would be harmed if the secret came out too soon. Every year there was a new reason to wait."
Margaret nodded. “Of course.”
Luca turned. “Why hide the footprints in my parents' wedding portrait?”
Margaret looked startled. “What portrait?”
He explained. She listened, and the color slowly left her face.
“Elena didn't hide the photograph to tell you Sofia gave birth to you,” she said. “She hid it because she wanted you to find the woman standing at Sofia's side.”
“There was no woman at her side,” Luca replied. “It was Sofia holding a baby, beside Elena.”
“Look again,” Margaret said. “In the mirror behind them.”
Claire opened the photo on her phone and enlarged the reflection. A sliver of white uniform. A face half hidden by the camera flash. A necklace with a small square pendant.
Margaret caught her breath.
“That is Marisol,” she whispered. “And she wore that pendant until the day she vanished.”
Luca stepped closer. “Where did she go?”
Margaret shook her head. “I never knew.”
Her phone rang. The screen showed a blocked number.
Nobody moved.
Margaret answered on speaker.
A woman's voice, husky with age, said, “Margaret, if the boy knows about his sister, tell him not to trust the clinic records.”
Luca leaned forward.
“Who is this?”
The voice trembled.
“Ask Vanessa Bellini what happened to the girl she calls her cousin.”
Then the caller hung up.
May you like
Claire watched Luca close his eyes.
Somewhere in Chicago, a woman had just turned a rumor into a new and terrible possibility.