Chapter 2 - THE WOMAN WHO STOLE NOTHING
The doctor stitched my palm just after midnight. My ankle wasn't fractured, but the ligaments were strained, and he sent me home with a brace, instructions to stay off it, and a warning that the cut had been deeper than it looked. I was grateful he'd explained everything without making me feel foolish for getting hurt.
By the time I called Mom, I'd decided to tell her a version of the truth.
"There was trouble at work," I said. "I'm safe. I need a few days to recover."
"What kind of trouble?"
"A man hurt me when I tried to leave a room. The police are involved."
She was quiet for a long time. Then she said, "Come home, Emily. Nothing in that house is worth your safety."
I looked at the discharge papers and thought about the balance in my checking account. "I will, Mom. I promise."
That was the first promise of the night I knew I could keep.
I stayed in the small apartment Mom rented on the North Side. She'd put clean sheets on the couch and left a bowl of soup warming on the stove. Her hair had grown back in silver wisps after treatment. When she saw the bruises forming around my wrist, she pressed her lips together but did not demand that I explain before I was ready.
The next morning, Daniel Price called. "Mr. Moretti would like to speak with you, if you're willing. You're under no obligation."
"About the recording?"
"About Claire. His attorney has located an address that may belong to her."
I almost dropped my phone. "Is she all right?"
"We don't know."
I met Luca and Celia in a quiet office downtown, not at the mansion. Luca had replaced the black dinner jacket with a plain navy sweater and looked more tired than powerful. Celia had arranged for a lawyer named June Park to speak with me separately before the meeting began.
June was direct. "You can report what happened without participating in Mr. Moretti's private investigation. If anyone threatens your employment, documents, or medical care, call me. I work for you, not him."
I liked her immediately.
When I joined Luca and Celia, a large photograph lay on the table. It showed a painting of a river in winter, its branches drawn in pale gold against a blue sky.
"This is The Winter Orchard," Luca said. "My mother bought it the year I turned sixteen."
"It's beautiful."
"It was supposed to be donated to the Chicago Children's Arts Museum when she died. Her trust made that instruction clear. Instead, the painting was reported missing twelve years ago, along with six others."
I studied the photograph. "And you believed Mara stole them?"
His face tightened. "Richard told me she'd authorized the shipment. He produced warehouse logs and a letter supposedly signed by her. She'd been my closest friend since college."
"More than a friend?"
"For a while," he said. "We were in love. It ended terribly."
I wished I hadn't asked, but he continued without irritation.
"She worked as a registrar for the family collection. She was the one person who could tell a genuine restoration mark from a newly copied one. Richard said she'd taken a commission to move the paintings overseas. A witness claimed to have seen her leave with a courier."
"Who was the witness?"
"The same company that issued the new valuation last month." He pointed to a name printed beneath the photograph. ASTER HOUSE FINE ART.
"Richard's gallery?"
"His principal investment, yes. I should have recognized the conflict."
Celia opened a file. "Aster House is now proposing to secure a twenty-eight-million-dollar credit facility against seven paintings. The application contains a schedule identifying the same works reportedly missing twelve years ago."
"How can you borrow against something you don't have?" I asked.
"If you convince a lender that you control the art, and you provide false documents, the application might get farther than it should," Celia replied. "We don't yet know if money was disbursed."
My throat went dry. "Does Luca own them?"
"No," Luca said. "My mother's trust owns them. And her trust says they belong to the museum when the legal requirements are completed."
"So someone could be trying to borrow against paintings meant for children."
He nodded once.
It seemed impossible that anyone would risk so much for a loan application. Then I remembered Vanessa slapping Claire over a bracelet she'd never touched. Small cruelties could protect enormous lies.
Daniel came in holding a narrow cardboard box. "The police released photographs of the dinner device. We have reason to think it was connected to Aster House's network during installation. The original remains with investigators."
He laid out enlarged images rather than the device itself. One showed the microphone disguised behind painted flowers. Another showed the frame's rear label. The painting had an invoice attached listing its price as four hundred thousand dollars, but the artist's signature was oddly faint.
"An appraiser will look at it," Luca said. "I won't ask Emily to pay anything."
June, who had joined us, leaned forward. "That commitment should be put in writing without requiring Emily to waive her claims."
"It will," he said.
A knock came at the door. Daniel answered, then looked toward Luca with a question in his eyes.
"You wanted Claire," Daniel said. "She's downstairs."
I stood too quickly. Pain flashed through my ankle.
Claire came into the office wearing jeans and an inexpensive winter coat. She looked thinner than I remembered. Her hair was cut close to her jaw, and she carried a tote bag that had been repaired with bright blue thread.
For a moment neither of us moved.
"Emily?" she asked.
"I'm sorry," I blurted out. "I should have stood up for you."
Her eyes shone, but she shook her head. "You were scared. I was scared, too."
Luca stepped forward. "Claire, I owe you an apology. And back pay if the dismissal was wrongful. I've asked Celia to arrange an independent review."
"I don't want charity," Claire answered. "I want my name cleared."
"Then let's start with what happened."
Claire placed the tote on the table. Inside were copies of schedules, text messages, and a small notebook with dates written in blue ink. She told us how Vanessa had accused her of stealing a bracelet after she found Richard in the household archive. Richard had been photographing storage invoices marked as private. Claire had asked why a list of museum paintings was mixed with wine-cellar expenses.
"They planted the bracelet in my cleaning cart," she said. "Vanessa made sure Luca saw it there. I begged her to check the cameras, but she said the system wasn't working that morning."
Luca closed his eyes briefly. "I accepted her explanation."
"Yes," Claire said. "You did."
He didn't argue.
She had spent five months cleaning offices after hours. Last week, Richard contacted her through an intermediary and offered compensation if she signed a statement claiming she'd assisted Mara Ellison in forging museum records. Claire refused. Yesterday, he ordered her to a meeting at the gallery. The other person in the room was Mara.
"Did you know Mara before yesterday?" I asked.
"No. I recognized her from old photographs. Richard brought her into a small office and said she could fix everyone's troubles by authenticating the paintings. She said, 'Show me the originals.' He wouldn't."
"Why go to the meeting at all?" Celia asked gently.
"Because he had copies of my immigration paperwork from an old employment application and threatened to send accusations to every employer who might hire me. I was born here, but he thought the threat would frighten me anyway."
June took notes. "Did they give you anything to sign?"
Claire drew out a folded page. It bore her name beneath a statement describing paintings she'd never seen. The signature block was blank.
"I kept it," she said. "I figured if I vanished, someone should know what they wanted."
Luca's voice was rough. "No one's vanishing today."
Claire gave him a tired look. "You can't promise that."
He accepted the correction. "Then I'll help you arrange protection through people who can actually provide it, if you want them."
She nodded toward June. "I want my own lawyer first."
"Good," June said.
Before leaving, Claire turned to me. "There was something else in that room. A shipping label on the desk. I couldn't read the address, but I remember the last three words."
"What words?" Luca asked.
"South Harbor Vault."
Celia's pen stopped moving.
"What?" Luca asked.
"That's where your mother kept the collection before it disappeared," she said. "The vault was supposed to have been emptied twelve years ago."
Claire looked down at the scarred blue thread of her bag. "Then somebody should explain why Richard had a current shipping label for it yesterday."
May you like
I pictured the microphone hidden inside the painting: a small black eye watching a room full of people. Someone had counted on our silence, our fear, and the fact that wealthy guests preferred not to see a servant bleeding.
For the first time, I understood that Claire's innocence and Mara's disappearance might be parts of the same story. The missing paintings were not merely valuable things. They were a trail someone had spent twelve years trying to bury, and we had finally found the first place to dig.
