Chapter 2 - THE WOMAN IN THE HALLWAY
I arrived at the hospital through an entrance intended for visitors, because Detective Ellis had advised me not to return to the estate before giving my statement. Outside the glass doors, people carrying flowers walked past people carrying blankets. A little boy was arguing with his father about a vending-machine sandwich. An elderly woman laughed into her telephone. It astonished me that ordinary life could continue while Matteo Costa lay somewhere in the building, fighting to stay alive.
Detective Ellis was younger than I'd expected, with a scar near one eyebrow and a manner that made silence feel less like punishment. Her partner, Detective Daniel Ortiz, offered me a paper cup of water. We sat in a small interview room behind the emergency department. They recorded my account and let me stop when my voice began to shake.
"Did you personally see Carlo put anything in the tea?" Ellis asked.
"No."
"Did you see him prepare it?"
"No. I saw him carry it upstairs in the same silver canister."
"Have you ever tasted it?"
"No."
"Then tell me what you did see."
It was a relief to hear a question that did not demand certainty I didn't have. I described the repeated visits, Matteo's complaints about his vision, and the way the cup always appeared after Carlo arrived. I admitted I had first smelled the tea while collecting laundry, not while inspecting the canister. I admitted that my grandmother's stories had been enough to frighten me, but not enough to identify a substance.
"Good," Ellis said when I finished. "Those distinctions matter."
Ortiz asked about the call I'd received the night before. I played the voicemail I'd captured after realizing the number had called twice. He made a note. No one promised to find the caller by lunchtime. The seriousness with which they treated that ordinary uncertainty made me trust them more.
When the interview ended, Nurse Shah appeared in the doorway. She'd been working through the night and looked as though a strong wind might carry her away. Her name badge read PRIYA SHAH, RN.
"Mr. Costa is awake for short periods," she said. "He asked whether the woman who stopped his tea was safe."
My throat closed. "Can I see him?"
"A few minutes. His doctors decide the rest."
I followed her through corridors smelling of disinfectant. At the entrance to the intensive care unit, Enzo stood with his phone in his hand. He looked relieved when he saw me, though relief sat awkwardly on him.
"You're protected," he said.
"From whom?"
"Anyone who would interfere with the investigation."
"That isn't an answer."
He considered me for a moment. "No. It isn't. Carlo is no longer allowed into this unit. He has lawyers making calls. He says the doctors were misled by a frightened employee and that you've accused him to get money."
I wanted to laugh. I'd worked double shifts to keep a roof over my head, and a man with several houses believed I had orchestrated all this for money I hadn't seen.
"I haven't asked Matteo for a cent."
"I know."
"You know because you checked my bank records?"
Enzo lowered his gaze. "Because I've seen you send half your wages out before you buy yourself new shoes. I asked Mrs. Vale about it once."
I felt exposed in a way I hadn't expected. "My finances are not everyone's business."
"You're right," he answered. "I'm sorry."
The apology was quiet. I was beginning to learn that quiet words could matter, provided someone acted differently afterward.
Matteo's room contained more machines than furniture. His face looked smaller against the pillow, and several wires disappeared beneath his hospital gown. His eyes opened when I entered. I stopped at the threshold, suddenly afraid he would be angry about the shattered cup.
"You made quite an entrance," he murmured.
My knees weakened. "I'm sorry about the carpet."
For the first time, a faint expression touched his mouth. "I've never liked that carpet."
Nurse Shah gave him a look that suggested he should save his energy. He obeyed for nearly ten seconds.
"Did Carlo hurt you?" he asked.
"No. Not physically."
"Did he threaten you?"
I thought of the phone call. "Someone did. The detectives know."
Matteo closed his eyes. When he opened them, anger had replaced the brief humor. "I put him in charge of the doctors because I thought he loved me."
"You didn't know," I said.
"I didn't ask enough questions."
A person with more confidence might have offered him comfort. I remembered the man who'd been too proud to accept a blanket from a nurse and too sick to sit upright. I also remembered the older staff who became silent whenever he entered a room. I didn't know how to hold both versions of him.
"Mr. Costa," I said, "I want you to recover. But please don't make promises about people getting punished because you're angry. Let the detectives find out what happened."
Nurse Shah glanced up, perhaps surprised that a maid was giving advice to a man whose name appeared in whispered conversations all over the city.
Matteo studied my face. "You think I don't know the difference?"
"I think being hurt makes it hard for anyone to see clearly."
He turned his head toward the window. "Maybe you're right."
When I left, a woman was waiting beside the elevators. She wore a long camel coat and carried a leather folder against her chest. Her dark hair was threaded with silver at the temples. She looked so much like Matteo around the eyes that I knew who she was before she spoke.
"I'm Lucia Costa," she said. "Matteo's sister."
I had heard of Lucia from the kitchen staff. Years before, she had trained as an attorney, refused to handle some family business, and moved to Philadelphia. At the estate, people spoke her name the way families speak of an old argument no one wants to finish.
"I know," I said.
"May I buy you lunch? Somewhere with a door we can close?"
I hesitated. "I've already spoken to the police."
"Good. You should. I'm not asking you to hide anything. I want to know whether Carlo was allowed to communicate with the doctors as a family representative or as Matteo's legal agent. Those are very different roles."
In the hospital cafeteria, Lucia spread several photocopied pages across a table. She had received them from Matteo's longtime attorney that morning. They were hospital liaison forms signed electronically a month earlier. Carlo's name appeared under PERSON AUTHORIZED TO RECEIVE UPDATES. On another page, however, a different description appeared: PERSON AUTHORIZED TO APPROVE NONEMERGENCY CARE ARRANGEMENTS.
"Did Matteo agree to this?" I asked.
"I don't know," Lucia said. "He was sick. The record shows his consent was collected remotely. I'm asking for the original documentation."
I traced a date without touching the paper. It was the day I'd found Matteo too weak to stand on his own. Carlo had arrived at two thirty with tea, and the doctors had changed the treatment plan afterward. I'd remembered the time because that afternoon Matteo had dropped a book, and I'd spent twenty minutes looking for the page marker that had slid beneath his bed.
"He wasn't using his computer that day," I said.
Lucia looked at me. "Can you be sure?"
"Only that he told me he couldn't focus his eyes well enough to read. I don't know what he did when I wasn't there."
She made a note. "That's a useful distinction."
The meal was chicken soup I barely tasted. Lucia never asked why I hadn't graduated from college or how I knew to recognize Matteo's symptoms. Instead, she wanted dates and witnesses. I found myself telling her about the Tuesday when I'd warned Enzo. She wrote it down carefully.
"People think power means you can prevent everything," she said. "Sometimes it just means everyone is afraid to tell you what they see."
I looked at the window, where the reflection of hospital lights blurred the gray sky. "I told them."
"You did," she replied. "And you should have been heard."
By late afternoon, I returned to my apartment with photocopies of my statement and a number for a victim-support coordinator. Mrs. Vale had sent a message saying my pay would continue while the investigators needed me away from the estate. I appreciated it, but the landlord's latest message still made my stomach knot. There was a past-due notice on the door when I arrived.
Inside, I found another envelope slipped beneath the mat. No stamp. No address. A photograph fell out when I opened it. It showed me outside the hospital that morning, my cheap blue coat wrapped around me, my face turned toward Detective Ortiz.
On the back someone had written, in deliberate block letters: EVERYONE HAS A PRICE.
For a moment I considered tearing it up. Then I remembered Ellis telling me not to disturb anything that might become evidence. I set the photograph on the kitchen counter, took pictures, and called her. My hand trembled so badly I had to dial twice.
"Don't touch it further," she said. "We'll send someone. Are your doors locked?"
"Yes."
"Can you stay somewhere else tonight?"
I stared at my apartment: the crooked lamp, the cracked bowl I'd bought at a yard sale, my mother's photograph in the windowsill. This was the only place I owned even a little of, and suddenly I was being asked to leave it.
"I can stay with a friend," I lied.
Ellis caught the hesitation. "Tell me if you can't. We'll find a safe option without making you agree to anything you don't understand."
After we hung up, I called Luis. He answered on the first ring.
"Can I sleep on your aunt's couch?" I asked.
"Yes," he said before I could explain. Then he lowered his voice. "Nia, you should know something. Mrs. Vale found a second service record. On the one day Carlo said he was out of town, Matteo still got the tea."
I looked at the photograph in my hand. "Who delivered it?"
"That's the part she can't explain. The entry has a signature. It's hers."
"Mrs. Vale's?"
"Yes. And she swears she never signed it."
May you like
Outside my window, headlights swept slowly across the street. I lowered the blinds.
The canister wasn't the only thing someone had handled. If Mrs. Vale was telling the truth, whoever was hurting Matteo had been preparing to make the household staff responsible all along.
