Chapter 3 - PAGE SEVENTEEN

Three days after the engagement party, I was still startled by the sound of breaking glass.
At Hannah's apartment, the dishwasher clicking shut could send my pulse racing. Her orange cat, Pickles, had taken possession of the couch I was sleeping on and seemed deeply offended by my medical supplies. I spent mornings with my leg propped on two pillows, waiting for the swelling to subside. The wound dressings were clean now. The deeper trouble was how easily my mind returned to Vanessa's face when she stepped between me and my crutch.
"You can't go back to pretending none of this happened," Hannah said over breakfast.
"I wasn't planning to."
"Good. Because you've apologized to that cat six times for making him move."
I looked at Pickles, who was glaring at me from a kitchen stool. "He seems powerful."
Hannah laughed. She was a dental receptionist with an apartment full of plants, mismatched cups, and the confidence of someone who had never worked in a house where a guest's stained napkin could be treated as a personal failure.
Detective Lee had asked us to preserve every threatening message. The police were attempting to trace the accounts, but one more arrived that morning: a photograph of Hannah getting off her bus. It was a precise, ordinary image, terrifying only because someone had chosen to take it.
I forwarded it to the detective, then locked my phone and stared at my hands.
"You can stop helping," Hannah said. "You don't owe these people your life."
"There's a woman missing."
"I know. But you don't have to find her yourself."
She was right, which made the advice harder to accept.
At eleven, Naomi called to ask whether I recognized a place in Elena's files. An independent accountant had found an entry marked E.R. BLUE / COMMUNITY ROOM / RETURN SLOT. Beside it was the number seventeen.
"Community room where?" I asked.
"That's what we're trying to establish."
Then I remembered a small scene from my first month at the mansion. Elena Rossi had brought a box of surplus books to the staff kitchen. She said they were destined for a neighborhood reading center on Halsted Street, a place where children could get tutoring while their parents worked late. I'd helped her tape the box shut.
"There's a reading room on Halsted," I said. "Near the old viaduct. Elena volunteers there."
Naomi asked me to give the information to Detective Lee and let investigators handle a search. I agreed. In theory.
In practice, I couldn't bear waiting through the afternoon without knowing whether the notebook was real. I made myself tea, opened an old workbook from my abandoned paralegal-certificate course, and forced myself to study evidence preservation. Four pages later, the tea was cold and I was staring at the same paragraph.
Luca called that evening. I had not expected him to use the number Naomi had given him, and for a moment I almost declined.
"I heard about the threatening photographs," he said. "Are you safe?"
"As safe as I can be with Pickles guarding the apartment."
"Who's Pickles?"
"A cat with a violent sense of property law."
His surprised laugh changed the air between us. Then he grew serious.
"I wanted to tell you something directly," he said. "The board has suspended all new transfers from East River. Beneficiary payments already owed are being handled through a supervised account while the records are reviewed. We don't want families punished because someone may have stolen from them."
"You keep saying 'someone.'"
"Because I don't yet have proof of who did what. I owe those families more than an accusation I can't support."
That answer impressed me more than a threat ever would have. Luca Moretti could frighten a room by standing up, but he was learning the harder discipline of not using fear as a substitute for evidence.
He asked about my follow-up appointment. I told him the cuts were healing, though I still needed the crutch. I also told him I wouldn't return to work at the mansion. There was a pause.
"I understand," he said. "You should have had a choice long ago."
"I always had one," I replied. "It just came with a terrible price."
The next morning, investigators searched the reading room with its director's permission. By noon, the notebook was located inside a hollowed-out book box used for storing old catalogs. Detective Lee invited Elena's sister Marina and her attorney to identify the handwriting.
They did not let me handle it. I was glad.
Naomi later showed me copies of three pages that the police had cleared for witness review. The blue book contained a running record of transfer instructions, voice messages, and account numbers. Elena had made dated notes in the margins, careful to distinguish documents she had seen from rumors she had merely heard.
Page seventeen was different.
It was a photocopy of a foundation board resolution, apparently authorizing North Meridian Advisory to administer the remaining East River funds. Beneath the text stood three signatures: Luca Moretti, Matteo Moretti, and a third trustee, an elderly woman named Teresa D'Amico.
At the bottom, someone had written in red ink: ORIGINAL WAS NEVER SIGNED.
Naomi explained that the note by itself could not establish forgery. Investigators would need independent records and comparison specimens. But something else bothered me. The margin beside Luca's signature held two tiny pencil lines, like marks used to align paper in a copying machine.
"Those weren't made by a pen," I said.
Naomi looked up. "What do you mean?"
"I worked in an office supply shop in college. Customers sometimes use alignment marks when they're assembling displays or tracing templates. You can see the ruler marks next to his name."
She photographed the detail to pass to the examiner. I felt a strange surge of pride. Cleaning rooms had taught me to notice dust beneath furniture and dents in wallboards. Apparently it had also taught me to pay attention when objects were slightly wrong.
The police also collected my uniform and the original dressings after staff documented them. Handing over the clothing felt strange. I had washed and ironed that uniform every week because looking neat was one of the few things I could control. Now the torn fabric and the dried blood might help establish what happened when I had no other witness.
Hannah drove me to a thrift store for loose trousers that wouldn't rub against the wounds. I counted the price of each pair automatically. At the register she bought two without asking permission, then waited while I protested.
"It's not charity," she said. "You covered my electricity bill when my hours were cut. Friends take turns."
I let her pay. It was harder than I expected, accepting something without promising to repay it immediately. Maybe that, too, was part of learning how to be safe.
By late afternoon, the internet had found a new way to punish me. A video showed me swinging an arm toward Vanessa during the engagement dinner. The clip began in the middle of the fall, cropped to omit the crutch and her foot beside it. Commentators called me a liar, a violent opportunist, and worse.
I watched it once before Hannah took the phone from my hand.
"You're not going to spend your evening defending yourself against strangers who think thirty seconds is a trial," she said.
"I just want somebody to believe me."
"I do."
The next day, a young catering assistant named Chloe Park contacted Detective Lee. She had been at the engagement dinner, stationed beside the champagne tower. Chloe said Vanessa had instructed her to move the carpet runner six inches toward the serving table shortly before I entered. She had also watched Vanessa shift my crutch out of reach after I fell. Chloe had kept the original video on her phone; its wider angle showed the full sequence.
When Naomi told me, I pressed my palms against my eyes until little stars swam across the darkness.
"Why didn't Chloe say anything that night?" I asked.
"She was frightened she'd lose her job. Her employer threatened to cancel her shifts after the edited clip appeared. She came forward anyway."
I knew exactly how much courage that had taken.
That evening Luca asked to meet in the lobby of Naomi's office, somewhere neutral and crowded. I agreed because the doctor had cleared me for short trips with the crutch. He brought no entourage inside, only Daniel waiting by the street.
"I saw the complete video," Luca said. "I'm sorry about what was posted."
"I fell because my leg was hurt. She didn't have to move the carpet to make me fall. But she wanted everyone to think I was incompetent."
"She wanted you discredited before you could talk about Elena."
I studied him. "You were going to marry her."
"Yes."
"How could you not know?"
He didn't answer quickly. "I liked how she made the house feel lively after my mother died. I wanted a future that looked uncomplicated. I kept dismissing smaller acts of cruelty as misunderstandings because admitting what they meant would have required me to act."
His confession carried no request that I comfort him.
Before we parted, Naomi received a call from Detective Lee. The notebook's page seventeen had led investigators to a storage company. Elena had rented a small locker under her own name, paid through the end of the month.
An employee had just reported that two men with false authorization papers attempted to empty it that morning.
May you like
One wore a staff badge from the engagement party.
And a tattoo of a black compass circled his wrist.