Chapter 7 - THE WITNESS AT THE PUMP STATION
Esther Price was found alive, but she was not free.
Detective Chen called us at six on a bitterly cold morning. A maintenance worker had heard someone pounding inside a locked office at the old Calumet pump station. Police arrived to find Esther trapped in a disused records room, dehydrated and frightened, with a bruise on her forehead. She had been left with a bottle of water and a warning that no one would find her if she tried to escape.
I went to the hospital with my father, though Detective Chen had warned that Esther might not want visitors. We waited in the corridor under a poster about hand hygiene while a nurse checked her blood pressure. Matteo arrived a few minutes later carrying a paper bag of breakfast rolls he hadn't had time to eat.
“She can refuse to speak to me,” he said. “I don't want her thinking my last name gives me a right to be here.”
“Good,” Dad replied. “Because it doesn't.”
Their relationship had become an odd, cautious truce. My father still distrusted the Romano family, but he had begun to believe Matteo was at least trying to choose a different path.
Esther asked for me first. She sat upright in a narrow hospital bed, her dark hair tangled around her face. When I entered, she looked at my bruised eye and began to cry.
“I helped write those lies about you,” she said. “Dominic dictated them, and I sent them to the reporters.”
“You didn't deserve to be locked in a room,” I told her.
“No. But I did hurt you.”
“I know.”
She looked down at her hands. “I was scared. He said he'd ruin my sister's career if I refused. She's a school principal. He knows everyone on her board.”
I pulled a chair beside the bed. “Tell Detective Chen what he made you do.”
“I will. But I need you to understand something first. The foundation wasn't just moving money between accounts. It was paying people to rewrite evidence.”
She explained that after the fire, a consultant working for Vincent had purchased copies of the initial incident notes before the report was finalized. Those notes mentioned a chained gate, a disabled alarm panel, and a possible second person seen entering the upper office. The final report omitted all three details.
“Who changed it?” I asked.
“An investigator named Dr. Hollis authorized the corrections. He said they were administrative.”
“Why keep the original?”
“Dominic needed proof that Hollis would stay quiet. Blackmail is a kind of insurance in his world.”
She reached into the pocket of her hospital robe and held out a small folded scrap. The police had already photographed it. She had hidden it inside the lining of her shoe after being taken to the pump station.
It was a list of payments, handwritten in her neat office script. One was to Hollis. Another was to Kells. The last was to a company registered in the name of Lewis Dane, the warehouse maintenance supervisor Grace had mentioned.
“That man's been missing since the fire,” Esther whispered. “Dominic always said he moved to Arizona. Last month I found his retirement benefits still being paid into a Chicago account.”
“Why would someone keep paying him?”
“So he'd stay quiet. Or because somebody else controls the account.”
Detective Chen entered, thanked Esther, and asked for permission to bring the investigator from the financial-crimes unit into the room. I stood to leave, but Esther caught my sleeve gently.
“Tell Matteo there was a meeting three days before Giuseppe died,” she said. “At the foundation office. I found the minutes. His father planned to turn over the accounts to outside auditors and freeze Dominic's access. Vincent was there. So was Celeste.”
I stared at her. “Celeste attended the meeting?”
“She signed the visitor log. Dominic brought her in after Giuseppe left.”
That afternoon, Matteo listened while I repeated Esther's words. He was standing in his father's old study, beneath shelves of leather-bound books and a framed photograph from a family fishing trip.
“I remember that week,” he said. “Celeste told me her father was helping plan a new charity partnership. I thought she was excited about it.”
“Were you dating then?”
“Not yet. We were friends. We started seeing each other the following winter.”
I felt a chill. “After the fire.”
He nodded. “She was at the funeral. Dominic introduced us properly that day. She said she knew how much my father meant to me.”
I thought about the timing. Celeste hadn't simply fallen in love with Matteo after helping conceal his father's death. Someone may have placed her in his life to make sure he never looked too closely at the Valenti family.
“Do you think your uncle arranged it?” I asked.
“I don't know. But I'm finally willing to ask.”
The door opened and Marco stepped inside, holding a tablet. “There's been a development. Kells's car was picked up by a traffic camera outside a private aircraft hangar last night. He met with someone using a vehicle registered to Dominic's holding company.”
“Dominic?”
“Can't confirm his face. But the man's height matches. The plane never took off. Both vehicles left separately.”
Matteo rubbed his jaw. “They're staying in the city.”
“Maybe because they still need something,” I said.
Marco looked toward the empty space where Giuseppe's portrait had hung. “The original ledger?”
“The police have copies,” Matteo replied. “The portrait has been preserved. The lake-house records are secured. What could they still need?”
I thought about Esther's missing colleague, Lewis Dane. Then I remembered the woman who had changed her name because she feared for her son.
“What about the witness?” I asked. “Grace saw Dominic at the warehouse. Lewis Dane may know what happened to Giuseppe inside the office. If Dominic can find either one, he can try to silence them.”
Matteo's face hardened. “I'll tell Chen.”
The detective had already arranged a protected interview for Grace. But when officers reached her temporary lodging that evening, they found the back window forced and a chair overturned. Grace was gone. Her phone remained charging on the table.
My stomach lurched. I called Dad, who was waiting at home with Lily. He answered on the second ring.
“She's missing,” I told him.
He made a low, pained sound. “Oh, no.”
“Please stay inside. Don't let anyone in.”
“I will. Hannah, listen to me. Maria was brave the night of the fire. She won't stop being brave now.”
It wasn't much comfort. For every witness who came forward, someone seemed to be waiting to pull them back into the dark.
Two hours later, an unsigned envelope arrived at the police station. Inside was a photograph of Grace seated in a dim room with her hands tied loosely in front of her. She was alive and looking straight at the camera. On the back, someone had written: THE JOURNAL FOR THE WOMAN. NO POLICE.
Matteo stared at the photograph. “They think I still have the original.”
Detective Chen nodded. “And they're willing to harm a witness to get it.”
He turned to me. “I can make a copy and give them what they want.”
“No,” I said. “You can't buy trust from people like that. They'll keep asking for more.”
“They have her.”
“And if you walk into a meeting alone, they could have you too.”
He looked away, fighting himself. I saw how easy it would be for him to return to the habits of the organization he commanded. Violence promised quick answers. Waiting for a plan felt unbearable.
Detective Chen put the photograph on the table. “We can use their demand to locate her. But we do it carefully and legally, with trained officers in charge.”
For a long time, Matteo said nothing. Then he nodded.
While officers searched for Grace, I spent an hour with my father in the hospital cafeteria. We drank terrible coffee and watched families wander between elevators, carrying flowers and paper cups. Dad said he used to drive past the old warehouse twice a week after the fire, hoping that if he stared at the empty windows long enough he would remember something useful. “I wasn't brave like Maria,” he told me. “I let myself get worn down.” I reminded him that he'd kept the dispatch sheet and the storage receipt when keeping them could have cost him everything. He shook his head, but I saw some of the weight leave his face. We were both learning that courage didn't always look like a dramatic rescue. Sometimes it looked like telling the same difficult truth after years of being ordered to forget it.
The next morning, police traced the paper used for the ransom photograph to a print shop near the old warehouse. A clerk remembered a man with a gold signet ring buying supplies and asking whether security cameras kept recordings longer than a week.
The ring in Grace's testimony.
May you like
Dominic was not only hiding in Chicago. He was circling the scene of his brother's death.
And someone had told him that the building would be demolished at sunrise on Monday.
