newspilot

Chapter 1 - THE VOICE THAT SHOULD NOT HAVE BEEN THERE

The little voice came from beneath my house, and it called me Daddy.

My eight-year-old daughter, Maisie, stood behind me in the living room. Her hands were twisted into the hem of her nightgown. She was trembling so violently that the small silver stars on the fabric seemed to move.

I held my breath. For a moment I wondered if exhaustion had created a sound that wasn't there. I'd returned from a long business trip only three hours earlier. It was after midnight, and the house was quiet except for the storm pushing against the windows.

Then the tapping came again.

Three knocks. A pause. Two knocks.

I knew that rhythm.

Anna had taught it to our daughters when they were four. Three for I am here. Two for I hear you. The girls used to tap it through their bedroom wall after we'd turned off the lights. Their mother had called it the star signal, because she said even a star far away could tell another star it wasn't alone.

Anna was dead. She had been dead for five years.

And one of those daughters had been dead for two.

Or so I'd believed.

“Daddy?” the voice whispered again. “Please don't shut it.”

I pulled at the edge of the oak panel. The board resisted, then lifted enough for a draft of cold, damp air to strike my face. Beneath the living room floor ran a narrow maintenance cavity I had never known existed. I could see a dark passage, an insulated pipe, and something pale beside it.

A hand.

Behind me, my wife screamed.

“Ethan, stop! You don't understand what you're doing!”

Victoria Rowan stood at the hallway entrance in a cream silk robe. Her face had turned almost gray. She looked from my hands to the opening, then toward the security panel beside the stairs.

“There's a child down here,” I said.

“It's dangerous. The supports are rotten. You'll collapse the floor.”

“Then call emergency services.”

She didn't move.

“Victoria.” I barely recognized my own voice. “Call them.”

She reached for my shoulder. “We have to close it first. We can explain later.”

Maisie made a small noise, like a frightened animal.

“Don't close it,” she said. “That's what she told me to do.”

I looked over my shoulder. “Who told you?”

Maisie stared at Victoria.

My wife began to shake her head. “She's having a nightmare. You know how she gets when she remembers the fire.”

I pulled my phone from my pocket and called 911 myself. I gave the dispatcher our address, explained that a child appeared to be trapped beneath the living-room floor, and asked for firefighters and an ambulance. When the dispatcher instructed me not to crawl into the cavity, I stayed beside the gap and kept speaking.

“Sweetheart, can you hear me?”

A pause. A breath that rattled.

“Yes.”

“What's your name?”

The answer came so quietly I almost missed it.

“Hazel.”

My heart seemed to stop.

Hazel Rowan had been six when a fire destroyed our family's cabin by Cedar Lake. We buried a small white coffin. I had watched Maisie place her sister's favorite toy horse beside the flowers. I remembered the funeral director placing a hand on my shoulder and explaining why I couldn't see the remains. I remembered signing documents while my hands shook.

For two years, I had told myself that the most terrible thing that could happen to a father had already happened to me.

“Hazel?” I whispered.

A narrow face moved toward the patch of light. There was dirt across the child's forehead. Her hair was tangled and cut unevenly, but her eyes were the same impossible shade of hazel-green Anna had passed to both our daughters.

“Daddy,” she said again. “You came.”

I felt myself lean forward, desperate to reach her. The dispatcher asked whether the child was responsive. I said yes. I told her I knew the child. I told her she was my daughter, and then I realized how insane that sounded.

Victoria stepped toward the front door.

“Where are you going?” I asked.

“To let the firemen in.”

“The door is already unlocked.”

She stopped.

“Stay here,” I said.

She looked at me with something I had never seen on her face before. Not fear for our family. Fear of being found out.

Maisie knelt beside me. I moved to keep her away from the exposed opening, but she leaned as close as safety allowed and tapped her fingers on the floorboards.

Three. Pause. Two.

From the dark came an answer.

Two. Pause. Three.

Maisie began to cry.

“Hazel used to do it backward when she wanted me to laugh,” she said.

I looked at my living daughter. After the fire she had told me that Hazel wasn't gone. She had said she saw a woman in a green coat take her sister toward the old service gate. I had accepted the official account that she was confused by smoke and grief. Victoria had encouraged therapy and asked that we not repeat Maisie's stories because they kept her from healing.

I'd mistaken silence for recovery.

The firefighters arrived nine minutes after my call. They removed a larger section of flooring, brought in lights, checked the structure, and sent one rescuer through the service access from the basement. Victoria kept insisting there was a risk of collapse. A captain asked her to stand back. For once, nobody deferred to her.

While they worked, I knelt beside the opening and talked to the child.

“I'm here, Hazel. They're coming for you.”

“Am I bad?” she asked.

“No.”

“She said I made everyone unhappy.”

“You haven't done anything wrong.”

“Will Maisie have to go away?”

“No, sweetheart. Neither of you is going away.”

I didn't know how I would keep that promise, but I knew I would not ask either child to earn the right to come home.

When a firefighter finally carried her out, the room went quiet. Hazel was thin and shivering beneath his rescue blanket. There were bruises on one wrist and a scrape across her cheek. She was taller than the child in my memory, yet so much smaller than an eight-year-old should have looked.

I rose, then stopped. I wanted to hold her, but she drew back when I reached toward her.

“Can I?” I asked.

She watched me carefully. Then she nodded.

I held her for perhaps three seconds before the paramedics needed to examine her. Three seconds was enough to feel her heart beating against my chest. Enough to know this wasn't a dream.

“She's dehydrated,” a paramedic said. “We need to get her to the hospital. Do you know how long she's been in there?”

I turned toward Victoria.

She stood beside the staircase, gripping the railing.

“How long?” I asked.

She said nothing.

A police officer who had arrived with the rescue team looked between us. “Sir, we'll need separate statements from everyone in the house.”

“Gladly,” I said.

I started to follow the stretcher, but Maisie caught my sleeve.

“Will she disappear again?”

“No.”

“You promised that when Mommy died,” she whispered. “And then Hazel disappeared.”

The words struck harder than anything Victoria had said.

I crouched beside her. “You're right. I promised something I couldn't make true. This time we're going to ask the police and the doctors for help, and we're going to make a plan together. I won't pretend I can do everything alone.”

She studied me through her tears, then reached for my hand.

At the doorway, Hazel lifted her head from the stretcher. She was looking past me toward Victoria.

“Don't let her take me to the orchard,” she whispered.

A paramedic leaned closer. “What orchard, sweetheart?”

But Hazel closed her eyes.

Victoria's knees seemed to weaken. She gripped the railing with both hands.

The officer noticed.

“Mrs. Rowan,” he said, “I'd like you to stay with us.”

I watched the stretcher disappear into the ambulance. Every instinct urged me to demand answers from my wife, to shout until the whole neighborhood knew what she'd done. Instead I took Maisie by the hand and followed the paramedics.

Answers could wait until both children were safe.

In the ambulance, Hazel lay beneath a warm blanket while a medic checked her pulse. She opened her eyes once and looked at me.

“Are you angry?”

“Not at you.”

“They called me Alice,” she said.

“Who did?”

“The people at the orchard. They said Hazel wasn't alive anymore.”

I kept my voice steady with difficulty. “You don't have to explain anything tonight.”

She nodded, but her fingers searched for my hand. I offered it and let her decide whether to take it.

She did.

As the ambulance pulled away, I saw Victoria through the mansion's illuminated windows, standing between two police officers. She was staring at the dark opening in our living-room floor.

For two years I had believed a fire had taken my daughter.

May you like

Now I knew someone had taken her afterward.

And the first person who had tried to stop me from finding her was my wife.

Related Stories

Other posts